By Gray14065360, May 08, 2012
A lovely wine. Smooth, fragrant and well-structured, but subtle, with well-integrated flavors. Very food friendly, but drinks well on its own.
Carl Roy 2009 Cab
By Whitworth12655824, April 13, 2012
Very smooth and tasteful. Robust flavor that goes down easy.
Great long finish
By goldfarb12569423, April 04, 2012
Beautiful rich Napa mountain Cab. Could use a few years, but is enjoyable now. Friends can't believe the price relative to the quality.
By Carignan216959, March 11, 2012
We loved it!!!
By Jace, February 06, 2012
Carl Roy is always a joy and the Spring Mountain is no exception. Terrific nose and hugely concentrated with clean primary fruits and nice structure. I think this will age for a decade.
By riesling10037993, December 07, 2011
Very good, a bit youthful and big, but a good value for sure. Thank you!
By bordeaux14079713, November 23, 2011
By Albarino231847323, October 16, 2011
My husband and I both liked it, we visited Spring Mountian in Napa a few years back and our favorite Napa wines all seem to be Spring Mountain. Carl Roy a bit more affordable than most these days, thankfully.
ALWAYS nice-will not disapoint
By Benz13810028, May 03, 2014
Very smooth and elegant almost as good as Cerl Roy's 2007 Howell Mountain which I felt was a five star wine
Carl Roy 2009
By Garvey12068136, March 02, 2012
Enjoyed enough to order a case yesterday
may i have another glass please
By french14159679, December 20, 2011
What a joy to savor the Carl Roy cab. Rich berry with a smooth finish.
Not bad but not great either
By Humphrey14124478, July 09, 2012
For the WineAccess price, this isn't necessarily a disappointment but I won't be ordering more. Found it to be inferior to wines like the Bugay. Concentration was average. No unpleasant character or aroma, just not the concentrated structured cab I was hoping for.
By Walters13676282, January 03, 2014
I was disappointed in this wine - surprisingly average with little structure and no typical Spring Mountain character. It did enhance my tomato sauce though!
By Gallivan14072264, March 24, 2012
The description of this certainly did not live up to the hype. I found the wine to be well made, but very ordinary & forgettable
Average rating: 3.86(265 ratings)