94+ Points | International Wine Cellar , September/October 2012

Less perfumed on the nose than the Chevalier-Montrachet, dominated today by smoky minerality, petrol and crushed rock along with a hint of clove.  Fat, rich and powerful but extremely backward and not yet revealing much personality.  Utterly primary Montrachet with a stony, slowly building finish and outstanding length.  With its powerful structure and impression of tannins, this will probably have an aging curve more like a red wine than a white.  Over the next decade, I'd rather drink the Batard, but this one may ultimately surpass it.

98 Points | Robert Parker's The Wine Advocate